Metal vs. Asphalt Shingles in Boise’s Climate: Which Lasts Longer?

get to know us

Compare costs, durability, and energy efficiency of metal and traditional roofing options.

Let’s be honest, no one dreams of spending their weekend thinking about roofing materials. But in Boise, where summers sizzle and winters bring snow and ice, your roof doesn’t get the luxury of just hanging out. The type of roof you choose makes a real difference in how long it lasts, how much you pay over the years, and how often you need to call for repairs.

So, the big question: metal or asphalt, who wins the durability battle in Boise’s unique climate?

Why Boise’s Climate is Tough on Roofs

Boise isn’t exactly gentle on housing materials. In the summer, roofs bake under 90- to 100-degree heat. Then, winter brings freezing nights, heavy snow, and the occasional hailstorm. Add in spring rains and big swings in day-to-night temperature, and your roof is working harder than most.

That means materials need to be tough, flexible, and low-maintenance, or else you’ll be shopping for a new roof sooner than you’d like.

How Local Conditions Affect Roofing Materials

In the Treasure Valley, summer UV exposure can cause asphalt shingles to dry out, fade, and lose protective granules faster than in cooler climates. Winter ice dams can sneak water under shingles, leading to leaks. Rapid freeze-thaw cycles, sometimes a 40-degree swing in 24 hours, push shingles to crack and curl.

Metal roofing responds differently. It reflects UV rays, sheds snow before it builds up, and is less prone to expansion and contraction damage. That resilience makes it a stronger candidate for Boise homeowners who don’t want constant maintenance.

Asphalt Shingles: The Classic Option

Asphalt shingles are the “standard issue” roof across much of America. They’re affordable upfront, easy to install, and come in lots of styles. But how do they hold up in Boise?

Pros of Asphalt Shingles:

• Lower initial cost compared to metal.
• Variety of colors and designs.
• Simple installation process.

Cons of Asphalt Shingles:

• Average lifespan is 15–20 years in Idaho’s climate, often shorter with severe heat or snow loads.
• Vulnerable to cracking from rapid freeze-thaw cycles.
• Shingles can loosen or blow off during high winds.

For homeowners watching their budget, asphalt can be attractive. But when you consider Boise’s hot summers and snowy winters, shingles may wear out faster than expected. If you’re starting to notice curling, cracking, or leaks, our guide on 7 Signs It’s Time to Replace Your Roof can help you know when it’s time for a change.

Metal Roofing: The Long-Term Contender

Metal roofing has become a popular alternative, especially in regions with weather extremes like Idaho. While it costs more upfront, the payoff is in durability and performance. Learn more in our article on How Metal Roofing Saves Energy in Idaho Summers.

Pros of Metal Roofing:

• Lasts 40–70 years depending on material.
• According to the U.S. Department of Energy, cool roofs that reflect sunlight can lower summer cooling costs and reduce wear from extreme heat.
• Sheds snow easily, reducing winter stress on the roof.
• Highly resistant to fire, hail, and wind.

Cons of Metal Roofing:

• Higher upfront investment.
• Can be noisier during heavy rain (though underlayment fixes this).
• Requires professional installation for best results.

Boise homeowners who plan to stay put for decades often find metal roofing is the smarter financial move in the long run.

Cost and ROI: Short-Term vs. Long-Term Thinking

The price tag is usually where asphalt seems like the winner. A basic asphalt roof can cost significantly less upfront than a metal roof. But here’s where Boise’s climate and long-term math come in.

Imagine you install an asphalt roof today. In 15 to 20 years, you’ll likely need a full replacement due to heat, snow, and freeze-thaw wear. Over a 40-year period, that could mean paying for two asphalt roofs. Metal, on the other hand, might cost more initially but can last 40–70 years with minimal maintenance. That means one purchase instead of two or even three.

Add in the extras: some insurers in Idaho offer discounts for homes with fire- and hail-resistant metal roofs. Plus, by reflecting heat, metal can trim summer cooling bills—something Boise residents appreciate when the thermometer hits triple digits. These savings add up, making metal not just a durability choice but a financial one.

Which Lasts Longer in Boise?

If you want pure longevity, metal roofing wins by a mile. Asphalt shingles in Boise’s climate may start curling, cracking, or shedding granules well before the 20-year mark. Metal roofs, on the other hand, can easily outlast most mortgages. You can read more about our expertise and local experience on our About Us page.

Many insurance providers also recognize the value of durable roofs. The Insurance Institute for Business & Home Safety notes that stronger roofing systems reduce wind-related losses, which can translate into lower insurance premiums for Boise homeowners.

Style, Maintenance, and Value

• Style: Asphalt gives you a “traditional neighborhood” look. Metal offers sleek, modern options or even metal shingles that mimic asphalt or tile.
• Maintenance: Asphalt may need frequent repairs after big storms. Metal typically requires little more than an occasional inspection.
• Home Value: A metal roof can increase resale value thanks to its long lifespan and energy efficiency, which buyers appreciate.

Expanding on Style & Curb Appeal

Today’s metal roofing isn’t just shiny silver panels. Homeowners in Boise can choose standing seam designs for a contemporary feel, metal shingles that look nearly identical to asphalt, or even options finished to resemble cedar shakes or clay tiles. That means whether you own a historic North End bungalow or a modern Meridian build, there’s a metal style that blends in or stands out in the right way.

Asphalt still offers variety, but it rarely matches the longevity of a metal roof that also looks sharp decades later.

The Bottom Line for Boise Homeowners

If you’re in Boise for the long haul, a metal roof is the clear durability champ. Asphalt shingles may be cheaper upfront, but they’re likely to need replacing sooner and possibly more than once in the same time a metal roof lasts.

Still, every home and budget is different. The best way to know what works for your property is to talk with local experts who understand Idaho’s weather challenges.

Check out our Our Services page to see installation and repair options, or visit our FAQ page for answers to common roofing questions. And when you’re ready, Contact Us to schedule a consultation.

Ready for a roof that actually keeps up with Boise weather? Give us a call today, and we’ll help you choose the right solution and install a roof that lasts.